1 Based on archaeological evidence of the
discovery of bears' skulls purposefully arranged in a circular fashion within a
Swiss cave before the period of Wurm glaciation (Campbell 1989: 2).
2 It is a peculiar feature of Christianity's influence on Occidental
thought which requires belief as a requirement for membership in a religious
tradition. In ritual practices generally, regardless of the culture, it is
always a matter of conjecture just what is actually happening inside the minds
of its participants. Earlier ethnographers such as Frazer, Tylor, and
Robinson-Smith may have fearlessly skated onto the thin ice of intellectual
projection of beliefs to tribal peoples, but contemporary anthropologists must
trace ritual actions and orientations through a major range of social
activities and other customs of the entire society before venturing any
hypothesis about what a people may or may not "believe".
3 A sign of how far anthropological thinking has "run" with a more
dynamic view of power, ideology, and hegemony is evidenced by Firth's 1972
criticism of Cohen's article as "reductionistic" since Firth believes Cohen
ignores the "whole range of problems concerned with men's conceptions of their
social order in moral and aesthetic terms..." (1972:87) as if these latter
categories developed autonomously!
4 Other relevant studies in the anthropology and ideology of death
would include Palgi and Abramovich (1984), Watson and Rawski (1987), Danforth
(1982), and Aries (1981).
5 This very issue has been at the center of the controversial Robert
Mapplethorpe photography exhibit of late 1989 and early 1990, and the resulting
campaign by Jesse Helms in the U.S. Senate to impose guidelines on the National
Endowment for the Humanities for funding art projects that conform to some kind
of "standard of decency" (i.e. a consensual ideology of morality).
6 That the topic remains "hot" is evidenced by the success of Bellah
et. al.'s Habits of the Heart (1985), advocating a return to "bibilical
republicanism". The forthcoming sequel, The Good
Society , is equally prescriptive (if no substantial changes are made
from the advanced manuscript copy I read as a participant in one of Bellah's
seminars) and is echoed by articles appearing in mainstream publications
usually reserved for secular politics, such as Glenn Tinder's "Can We Be Good
Without God?" in the December 1989 Atlantic Monthly.